An early attempt at the understanding of the nature of cerebral blood flow
(CBF) was made in the late 1770s when Monro proposed that the quantity of
blood flow within the head must be the same or nearly so at all times. He
believed that because the brain is enclosed in bone and it is
incompressible, the volume of blood within the cranium also has to be
constant. Although this is basically correct, a false assumption was also
made: that the vasculature is passive and incapable of actively changing its
diameter. The later work of Roy and Sherrington in the late 1800s
established an active role for the vasculature following observations of the
pial vasculature through cranial window preparations.
A major step toward quantitation of cerebral blood flow was made in the
1920s with the capability of obtaining jugular bulb blood samples, which in
turn made possible a measure of the arterial to jugular venous O2
difference. This approach subsequently laid a solid scientific foundation
for our current understanding of cerebral blood flow physiology and
established the dominant role of CO2 as a regulator of
cerebral blood flow.
In 1945 Kety and Schmidt described a method of quantifying cerebral blood
flow in humans, based on the Fick principle, that utilized nitrous oxide, a
metabolically inert and highly lipid-soluble gas, as the tracer of blood
flow. The Fick principle had stated that the quantity of a gas taken up by a
tissue per unit of time (Qi) is equal to the
quantity entering it via the arterial blood minus the quantity leaving in
the venous blood: dQi/ldt = Fi
(Ca - Cv), where Fi is equal
to blood flow and Ca and Cv are equal to the arterial and
venous gas concentrations, respectively. Knowing the time course of the
changes in the inert gas concentration in the arterial blood flowing into
the brain and the venous blood leaving it, as well as the blood/brain
partition coefficient, enables one to calculate the average cerebral blood
flow. The governing relationship as characterized by Kety and Schmidt for a
single tissue compartment. i, is
Ci(T) = λikiCa(µ)e-kj(T-µ)dµ
where flow is Fi = λiki. The
input functions for this equation are the partition coefficient (λi
) the flow rate constant (ki), the timedependent tracer concentration in
the arterial blood Ca(µ). and
the time-dependent tracer concentration in the venous blood. For this
relationship the tissue concentration (C,T) is assumed to be equal to the
venous blood content divided by λ. This equation is then valid for
saturation or desaturation studies depending on the boundary conditions that are
set. This measurement of global cerebral blood flow with nitrous oxide required
the following assumptions: (1) blood flow is in a steady state during the period
of study and is not affected by the tracer. (2) the venous blood from the
superior internal jugular vein is representative of the mixed cerebral venous
blood with no contamination from extracerebral blood, (3) the period of
measurement is long enough to allow equilibration of gas in the brain with the
cerebral venous blood, (4) no significant arterial-venous shunts are present in
the brain, and (5) the value of the partition coefficient of the inert gas is
representative of the entire brain. The initial studies with nitrous oxide
demonstrated that blood flow studies with this tracer did meet the above
assumptions under most situations, the exception being in a region of disturbed
physiology, where arteriovenous shunting may be significant and where the
partition coefficient is likely to be altered.
A major advance toward the broad
clinical application of cerebral blood flow measurement came with the
substitution of radiolabeled 85Kr for nitrous
oxide and scintillation counting as the direct measure of tracer movement within
the tissue, the latter measure being substituted for the difference of the
arterial and venous concentrations of the tracer. This approach provided a
regionality of blood flow determination that was lacking in the global blood
flow measures provided by nitrous oxide, but this was significantly hampered by
a weak signal and contamination from extracranial emissions. Initially this was
dealt with experimentally by the injection of 85Kr
directly into the internal carotid artery and by scintillation counting over the
cortex. Subsequently with the substitution of the gamma emitter. 133Xe. for
85Kr. higher and more adequate counting rates were obtained through the skull.
The application of this technique with internal carotid artery injection then
became widely utilized. both clinically and experimentally, as a means of
obtaining regional CBF measurements. Because this approach requires an internal
carotid artery catheter, its application has generally remained limited to
situations where patients were undergoing angiography.
A broader approach became possible,
however, with the work of Obrist, who, utilizing a multi compartmental analysis
of the Kety-Schmidt equation, was able to divide the washout curve into three
components, with the extracranial contamination appearing as a well-defined,
late washout. If this contamination is subtracted from the remaining fast (gray
matter) and slow (white matter) curves, an analysis of flow can then be done,
with an additional correction being made for the recirculation of gas. The later
measure was made by a separate recording of the end tidal
133Xe concentration as an indirect measure of the capillary (and
therefore arterial) concentration of the gas. As a "noninvasive" inhalation
study, 133Xe inhalation flow determinations
have been shown to maintain the numerical reliability of the intracarotid
injection method. In recent years most centres have turned to intravenous bolus
introduction of 133Xe as a simpler means of
delivering the tracer. Refinements have permitted a relatively short period of
data acquisition (10 min) during the clearance phase in which only the fast
"gray matter" flows are extracted, again without significant loss of validity
against the intracarotid technique. Commercially available units utilizing this
methodology commonly incorporate about 16 to 32 NaI scintillation counters,
which are placed about both hemispheres so that each is perpendicular to the
surface of the brain. The ultimate in collimation was developed in Lassen's
laboratory. where 254 independent collimators were made into a unilateral array.
Elegant studies of regional flow disturbance in disease and during activation
studies of physiologic stimulation have been demonstrated with this technique.
Portable 133Xe cerebral blood flow units
utilizing four to five probes over each hemisphere are now available, permitting
studies to be performed at the bedside.
The 133Xe
methodology, however, suffers from a number of significant limitations. Counts
arising from extracranial tissues still provide a signal contamination, as do
emissions arising from the opposite hemisphere. This technique is
dependent on the use of "normal" partition coefficients, which in diseased
states can alter flow values by as much as 50 percent. Although a careful
analytic approach to data analysis with this technique has been able to
positively identify the side of a cerebral infarction in 80% of the cases in
which a stroke was evident on computed tomography, regions of no flow may be
totally missed. This technique may detect raised or normal flow in a region of
no flow because counts from the hyperaemic rim can overshadow the area of low ,
or no flow just below it. As a major limitation of this technique, this
"lookthrough" phenomenon has prompted the development of a single photon
emission computed tomography (SPECT) imaging system for 133Xe.
Due to Compton scatter and a weaker signal from central regions,
133Xe SPECT still suffers from poor resolution,
especially centrally within the brain. This technology is also limited because
of independence on "normal" partition coefficient values (λ). Tomographic CBF
measurements with 133Xe are best acquired with
dedicated multi-head rotating cameras. A single rotating gamma camera can be
utilized with 133Xe, but the time for adequate
data acquisition may be over 1 h compared with 20 to 30 min for multi-head
units.
Other quantitative and regionally
specific techniques for blood flow determination include positron emission
tomography (PET)2 and stable
xenon-enhanced tomography (Xe/CT). The major of PET is its ability to measure
not only flow, but also a theoretically limitless list of other
potentially vital parameters at the same time. The relatively high cost of
acquisition and its requirement for short-lived isotopes make PET a demanding
technology requiring a team of individuals, thus limiting its potential for wide
availability. Interpretation of PET-derived physiologic data is also limited
due to a lack of direct anatomic correlation, and quantitative reliability is
weakened by a dependence on numerous physiologic assumptions which do not
necessarily pertain in disease states.
Another tomographic approach for
acquiring cerebral blood flow information involves the inhalation of 26 to 33
percent stable xenon, an inert radiodense gas which is highly lipid-soluble, as
a marker of flow combined with transmission computed tomography. For this
technique, CT scans obtained before and during approximately 4.5 min of
xenon-oxygen inhalation are utilized to record the movement of this
lipid-soluble and radiodense gas into the brain substance. Because the
relatively slow process of diffusion of this agent is being characterized, scans
obtained at 1-min intervals, provide the required data. Rapid scanning
techniques with incremental table movements permit data acquisition at three or
more additional levels during each inhalation sequence. The end tidal xenon
concentration as measured by a thermoconductivity analyzer is utilized to
indirectly record the arterial concentration during the buildup and/or washout
of xenon. This information, plus the degree of image enhancement, is then used
to derive λ and the local cerebral blood flow by multi variable analysis.
Concurrent studies using radiolabeled microspheres, iodoantipyrine. and
133Xe have shown excellent correlation with Xe/CT
CBF. Anatomic resolution is high, approaching the resolution of the CT scanners,
with equal quantitative accuracy within the center and on the surface of the
brain. Clinical studies suggest that this method has the potential for broad
application as a noninvasive, repeatable means of obtaining clinically useful
CBF information. Although it has been shown that xenon moderately alters
cerebral blood flow and may alter the sensorium of 10 to 15 percent of
individuals, moderate flow activation does not significantly alter flow values.
although sensorial effects can at times make it difficult to obtain studies
without motion.
Qualitative information about
cerebral blood flow is also being provided by two older and four newer
approaches. Clearance curves of 99mTc-labeled
technetium pertechnetate combined with rapid data acquisition on a
single-crystal Anger camera has been utilized for a decade to provide
information about the movement of blood within comparative blood pools. The
absence of supratentorial flow by this technique has become a standard test for
brain death. The same type of data, but with better localization, is also being
provided by rapid CT scanning following an intravenous iodine bolus. Studies at
the level of the middle cerebral arteries or at the level of the brain stem have
been shown to provide a readily accessible means of evaluating regional
asymmetries of movement within blood pools. Because of the broad availability of
this technology and the possible importance of flow asymmetry, this technique
has a broad potential application for the assessment of regional blood flow.
New radiopharmaceuticals combined
with SPECT imaging have received much attention of late. SPECT CBF derived with
radiolabeled isotopes that behave as biological microspheres today provide
relatively high-resolution three-dimensional qualitative CBF imaging. While
rotating angle cameras provide information for the entire intracranial volume,
such studies require prolonged acquisition times (>40 to 60 min). Newer
dedicated multihead SPECT units provide more rapid acquisition and higher
resolution. Normally, repeat studies are performed at 24-h intervals, allowing
tracer clearance. Repeat studies at briefer intervals can be performed using the
fractional dosing of a single study. Quantitative data can be obtained if a
reference arterial blood curve for tracer activity is acquired.
Diffusion imaging with magnetic
resonance imaging provides information concerning the presence or absence of
blood movement. The combination of excellent anatomic imaging and the ability to
identify the absence of flow should have direct clinical utility, especially if
linked to MR spectroscopy. At this time, MRI is unable to differentiate
gradients of flow unless diffusible tracers of CBF such as fluorocarbons are
combined with imaging.
Direct monitoring of cortical blood
flow is available today utilizing either thermal dilution or laser Doppler
technologies. Both techniques are able to record flow changes repeatedly and
provide information from a very focused region of only the outer few millimetres
of the cerebral cortex. Both are limited by the inability to maintain fixation
with the cortical surface, so that the interpretation of variations in flow may
be complicated by uncertainty as to whether the probe has remained in position.
Transcranial Doppler (TCD) velocity
measurement of intracranial vessels in and directly about the circle of Willis
is now widely available. This relatively simple and low-cost bedside measurement
can be made frequently or continuously. Although a single velocity measurement
is not tightly linked to CBF, the change of velocity induced by a physiologic
challenge is related to a proportional CBF change. This provides a valuable
means of assessing the response to diagnostic and therapeutic efforts. TCD has
also been very useful for recording the occurrence of cerebral emboli.
Three additional approaches to
cerebral blood flow measurement are applicable only in the laboratory.These are
autoradiography with iodo[14C]antipyrine,
sequential injections of different radiolabeled isotope microspheres, and
hydrogen clearance techniques.
Autoradiography utilizing iodo[14C]antipyrine
as a diffusible indicator of flow has proved to be a highly quantitative means
of obtaining data concerning flow with a high degree of spatial resolution. For
this study the animal needs to be sacrificed shortly after the intravenous
injection of iodo[14C]antipyrine. The brain is
then removed and frozen to -70°, followed by thin sectioning and application of
tissue slices to radiographic plates for 5 to 6 days. Multiple sequential
arterial blood samples are used to provide the arterial input function. The
emission densities on the photographic plates are then interpretable as measures
of blood flow which contain a high degree of spatial resolution. The major
limitation of this approach is that it permits a measure of flow at only one
point in time, although some work has suggested that two isotopes with
differential counting can be used to record flow at two points in time.
Radiolabeled microspheres measuring
6 to 8 µm in diameter provide a
nondiffusible means of measuring flow. Microspheres of this size are extracted
into the microcirculation at a rate of over 90 percent for a single pass through
the cerebral circulation. By recording the rate of extraction of radiolabeled
isotopes from the arterial circulation and then directly counting the number of
counts in each tissue volume, blood flow data are obtained. Currently up to five
independent isotope injections 141Ce,
133Sn, 85Sr,
95Nb, 46Sc) and
therefore blood flow determinations can be made after isotope separation
utilizing a matrix algebra approach for the solution of simultaneous equations.
The major disadvantage of this approach in a laboratory is that a volume of 8 x
8 x 8 mm is typically required to obtain adequate counts for reliable
statistical determinations.
The third approach involves
measuring the clearance of hydrogen gas from about a reference platinum-iridium
probe previously placed within the brain substance. Fine probe diameters (0.01
in) with exposure of only the terminal 2 mm are commonly being utilized. An
array of as many as six simultaneous probes are currently being used, and this
approach has been shown to provide a highly reproducible and locally specific
means of repeatedly determining local cerebral blood flow. This technique has
the advantage of repeatability with the opportunity to make flow calculations
every 10 to 15 min for days or even weeks. A critical review of this topic has
suggested that the tissue volume of study may be 5 x 5 x 5 mm. The only major
limitation to this approach is that the data acquisition is limited to only the
immediate region about the tip of the probe, which does require disturbance of
the tissue to be studied by its placement.
Blood flow is an important monitor
of cerebral function and impaired blood flow is often the pathway through which
cerebral injury occurs. Many technologies, each having advantages and
disadvantages, have become available for the measurement of CBF. Choosing the
most appropriate CBF tool will depend on the particular study subject and the
specific question to be answered.